The Quiet Revolution in Plasmonic Sensing
Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) has long stood at the forefront of optical sensing technologies—renowned for its label-free detection, real-time analysis, and ultra-sensitivity to minute changes in the refractive index (RI) of nearby media. In biological, chemical, and environmental diagnostics, SPR sensors provide a reliable window into molecular interactions, gas-phase analytes, and even volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in exhaled breath.
Traditionally, the gold standard in SPR has quite literally been gold. Its chemical stability, ease of functionalization, and consistent plasmonic response have made it a mainstay in sensor design. But as demands for sharper resonance curves, lower cost, and tunable sensitivity increase, gold is slowly being outclassed—quietly but convincingly—by copper.
If you are interested in collaborating on surface plasmon resonance-based research, we are open to discussions. We have our own. software algorithm and experimental facility in-house.
Recent multilayer SPR designs incorporating copper (Cu) in place of gold (Au) are showing sharper dips, higher sensitivities, and cost-effectiveness, particularly when combined with high-index chalcogenide films and advanced 2D materials. One such architecture—NaF–Cu–TiO₂–ChG–BP—emerges from this study as a compelling blueprint for next-generation optical sensors aimed at applications like early-stage lung disease detection.
Core Principles of Surface Plasmon Resonance
SPR relies on the excitation of collective electron oscillations—surface plasmons—at the interface between a metal and a dielectric. In the Kretschmann configuration, p-polarized light passes through a high-index prism and impinges upon a thin metal film. When the incident angle matches the resonance condition:
$$
\frac{2\pi}{\lambda} n_p \sin(\theta_{\text{SPR}}) = \text{Re} \left[ \frac{2\pi}{\lambda} \sqrt{ \frac{\varepsilon_m \varepsilon_s}{\varepsilon_m + \varepsilon_s} } \right]
$$
…the energy couples into the surface plasmon wave, producing a sharp dip in the reflected intensity. The position of this dip (the resonance angle) shifts when the refractive index of the external sensing medium changes—forming the basis of detection.
Two key performance metrics are:
- Sensitivity: $$
S_\theta = \frac{\Delta \theta_{\text{res}}}{\Delta n}
$$ - Figure of Merit (FOM): $$
\text{FOM} = \frac{S_\theta}{\text{FWHM}}
$$
Why Copper Is Outperforming Gold
While gold has been prized for its inertness, it comes with trade-offs. Its broader reflectance curves, lower electrical conductivity compared to copper, and relatively poor adhesion to biomolecules without additional surface treatments limit its performance in advanced multilayer structures.
In contrast, copper exhibits:
- Higher electrical conductivity,
- Narrower resonance dips under optimized conditions,
- Better performance in layered designs when paired with high-index dielectrics,
- Lower cost, improving scalability for disposable or mass-produced sensor platforms.
Copper is more prone to oxidation, but this challenge is mitigated in this design by embedding it within a protective multilayer architecture, isolating it from reactive environments.
Simulation results comparing Cu, Au, and Ag layers reveal that the copper-based system achieves a steeper and deeper SPR dip, outperforming both gold and silver in sensitivity and resonance sharpness.
The Multilayer Architecture: NaF–Cu–TiO₂–ChG–BP
This sensor design is an intelligently engineered stack optimized for field confinement, plasmonic coupling, and reduced damping:
- NaF Prism (n ≈ 1.32) – Low-index substrate enabling stronger angular contrast.
- Copper (42.4 nm) – Plasmon-supporting metal with superior conductivity.
- Chalcogenide Glass (Se₆₀Te₂₀Ge₁₅Sb₅, 41 nm) – High-index layer (n ≈ 2.98 at 700 nm), enhances evanescent field confinement.
- Titanium Dioxide (TiO₂, 29.19 nm) – Coupling layer that improves impedance matching.
- Black Phosphorus (17 nm) – Anisotropic 2D material that amplifies local field intensity.
TiO₂ narrows the resonance by reducing radiative losses. BP enhances anisotropic absorption and field localization, which is critical for detecting low concentrations of VOCs.
Optimization for Sensitivity: Tuning the Layers
Layer-by-layer tuning yields optimal performance:
- Cu Layer: Optimal at 42.4 nm; thinner layers result in poor coupling, while thicker layers cause over-damping.
- ChG Layer: Optimal thickness ~41 nm; balances high field confinement and low absorption loss.
- TiO₂ Layer: Optimized at 29.19 nm for maximum impedance matching.
- BP Layer: Outperforms MoS₂ and graphene, providing sharper and deeper resonance dips.
This configuration delivers:
- Sensitivity: ~100.1°/RIU
- FOM: ~33 RIU⁻¹
- Detection Limit: ~1.38 × 10⁻⁵ RIU
- Refractive Index Range: 1.001 to 1.009 (VOC window)
Application Potential: Breath Analysis and Beyond
Human breath contains trace levels of VOCs like isoprene and toluene, which slightly shift the RI of the sensing medium. This SPR sensor is capable of detecting these changes with high precision.
Angular interrogation mode enhances precision and reduces noise. Contour maps across RI and wavelength domains confirm high angular sensitivity and minimal spectral distortion between 690–710 nm.
Trade-Offs and Design Takeaways
Key lessons for optical sensor engineers:
- Copper, when encapsulated properly, matches or outperforms gold.
- High-index chalcogenide films enhance field confinement.
- Thin TiO₂ layers improve impedance matching without adding damping.
- Black phosphorus offers superior performance over other 2D materials in this configuration.
Each design choice affects resonance sharpness, sensitivity, and damping.
Conclusion: Copper’s New Role in the SPR Landscape
This study shows copper isn’t just a cost-saving alternative to gold—it can outperform it. When paired with chalcogenide glass, TiO₂, and black phosphorus, copper delivers sharper resonance, greater sensitivity, and a lower detection limit.
The NaF–Cu–TiO₂–ChG–BP configuration is a highly tunable and cost-effective platform for breath-based diagnostics and beyond. As the field shifts toward real-world, deployable sensors, copper is proving to be a strong candidate for mainstream SPR sensing technologies.
Our research publication. Is publishing a reputed journal. We are also open for collaboration. You can read our publication here
Check out YouTube channel, published research
you can contact us (bkacademy.in@gmail.com)
Interested to Learn Engineering modelling Check our Courses 🙂
--
All trademarks and brand names mentioned are the property of their respective owners.The views expressed are personal views only.
